Indicator history

Close Window

Are there political parties that express racist or xenophobic sentiments/discourse in the form of hate speech or promote an anti-migrant and/or anti-minority agenda?

Code:
RED33
Key Area:
Political Parties-organisations - Racist & Xenophobic Discourse
Strand(s):
Racism
29/12/2011 - 13:35
Short Answer

Yes.

Qualitative Info

The Austrian Freedom Party (FPÖ) repeatedly expresses racist and xenophobic sentiments and discourse. The following incidents are some examples:

In 1993, the FPÖ initiated a referendum “Österreich zuerst” (Austria First) demanding amongst others the inclusion of an article in the constitution that Austria is not an immigration country, a ban on immigration, an obligation to provide evidence of identity for foreigners at the work place, an increase of executive officers to improve the detection of “illegal” migrants, the immediate expulsion of migrant criminal offenders, the reduction of students with a first language other than German in schools and the establishment of a foundation in order to prevent migration. The referendum was supported by 416,531 persons, which means that the success was limited compared to other referenda. The referendum also caused enormous protest. A Lichtermeer (sea of light) was organised which was the biggest demonstration since 1945.

In 2008, the city councillor of the city of Graz, Susanne Winter (now Member of the Austrian Parliament), voiced xenophobic and anti-islamic sentiments during a new years meeting of the FPÖ. She said that Austria was struck by an immigration tsunami and that the Quran was written during an epileptic seizure. Furthermore she declared that child abuse was wide spread among Muslims. In 2009 Winter was sentenced to a fine of 24,000 Euro and to three months on parole because of Verhetzung (racist incitement).

In 2009, Martin Graf, member of the Austrian Freedom Party (FPÖ) and Third President of the National Council, fiercely attacked Mr Muzicant, the president of the Jewish Faith Community. In a comment for the FPÖ party paper (Neue Freie Zeitung), he posed the question whether Mr Muzicant should not be regarded as the “foster father of anti-fascist leftist terrorism”. This was a reaction to Mr Muzicant’s statement that he was reminded of Goebbels when listening to Mr Kickl, the general secretary of the FPÖ. Mr Graf also called into question the anti-fascist fundamental consensus of Austrian post-WWII politics.

The FPÖ expresses racist and xenophobic sentiments and discourse especially during election campaigns:
• During the EU elections in May 2009 the Austrian Freedom Party (FPÖ) put forward the electoral slogan “Abendland in Christenhand” (The West in Christian Hands) and “Time for a Reckoning.” Various Christian churches criticised the slogan as being a misuse of religion and Christianity. However, the FPÖ General Secretary Herbert Kickl defended the slogan by referring to the “danger of a creeping Islamisation” and stated that the FPÖ wouldn’t “be shut up by the Church council.”
• During the election campaign 2010 leading up to the Vienna city council election the FPÖ announced several anti-islamic and xenophobic slogans by poster: The slogan  "Mehr Mut für unser Wiener Blut. Zu viel Fremdes tut niemand gut" (More courage in Vienna Blood. Too much foreigners are not good for anybody) was criticised by other Parties and by NGOs as being xenophobic. Another slogan was "Wir schützen freie Frauen" (We protect free women).
• In 2010, during the election campaign in the federal state Styria the FPÖ published the internet game Moschee Baba (Mosque Bye Bye). The players had to fire on Muezzins standing on top of minarets.

The Dokumentationsarchiv des Österreichischen Widerstandes (Documentation Centre of Austrian Residence) documented a selection of xenophobic, anti-Semitic and racist statements by members of the FPÖ. However, it stopped its documentation in 2001. The report of the German Office of the Protection of the Constitution also mentions the FPÖ several times. It especially refers to the anti-Islamic sentiments of the Party.

Although the FPÖ is the party which is said to express and spread racist or xenophopic sentiments and statements most frequently there are also other parties which voice such sentiments repeatedly: For example the Carinthian Governor Gerhard Dörfler, member of the Alliance of the Future of Austrian (BZÖ), was reported to have made racist comments during a press conference for the ORF programme “Wenn die Musi spielt”. The BZÖ politician received the crooner Robert Blanco by telling a racist joke. The incident was discussed in several media. The Carinthian SPÖ made public a few days later that Dörfler had also told Blanco to “wash his face now and again,” and demanded a public apology for these discriminatory comments. The BZÖ denied the second incident in a press release; an apology for the racist joke was not forthcoming. Dörfler himself dismissed the criticism as “artificially stirred up.” He had told the joke “in a spirit of fun” and it was not intended to be insulting. “Should we ban the children's book ‘Ten Little N...[*]’ in Carinthia?” he asked the Austrian Media Agency (APA). Blanco commented in a newspaper interview, calling it, “a harmless joke, that I don't find discriminatory."

The ECRI Report on Austria (2010) points at some worrying developments. First of all it is concerned about the advance of far-right parties, which are openly exploiting prejudices against minorities, immigrants, refugees, asylum seekers, Jews and Muslims. It especially refers to statements and speeches during election campaign, which stigmatise in particular migrants, refugees, asylum seekers and Muslims and recommends to the Austrian authorities to systematically condemn all forms of racism, xenophobia and antisemitism in political discourse. It also suggests to adopt measures to combat the use of racially inflammatory or xenophobic discours by political parties or their representatives. 


Sources:

Represented in government/parliament?
Groups affected/interested Migrants, Refugees, Muslims, Ethnic minorities, Religious minorities, Linguistic minorities, Asylum seekers
Type (R/D) Extremism - organised Racist Violence, Anti-migrant/xenophobia, Anti-semitism, Islamophobia, Afrophobia, Arabophobia, Religious intolerance, Inter-ethnic, Nationalism
Key socio-economic / Institutional Areas Political discourse -parties - orgs
External Url
Situation(s)
Library